NATIONAL INDEMNITY CO  10% owner 1,800,000 $62.19 $1.11946E8 7.1889E7

NATIONAL INDEMNITY CO  10% owner 681,000        $63.43 $4.31969E7 7.257E7

NATIONAL INDEMNITY CO  10% owner 1,882,000 $61.65 $1.16031E8 7.4452E7

It should be noted that National Indemnity is a Berkshire Hathaway company.  It’s an Omaha based insurance company that Buffet purchased on behalf of Berkshire. If memory serves correct I believe this was one of first insurance companies he purchased and hence the beginning of his “float”  investing career.  The story of Buffett and National Indemnity is covered in some detail in “The Snowball” which I would highly reccomend reading.

The only reason I bring this up is because when reading information about insider purchases and sales you have to keep in mind that it might not always be clear who is purchasing the stock. In this case someone not familiar with Berkshire and it’s history of  buying BNI stock might not realize who is actually making the purchase.  As far as insider information goes InsiderCrow is the best site I have found so far for that info but please let me know if you have any others you use. Insider filings are available from the SEC site, but the search functionality on InsiderCrow is far better.

Back to BNI. Well I think there are two major things to consider:

1. Rail is the cheapest way to move goods across the country. When people start spending money again and gas prices work their way back up (both of which will happen eventually, nay sayers be damned) railroads will be in high demand.

2. Moat. This is a no brainer. When it come to moats railroads have it locked down. The threat to their competitive advantage (Moat) is that a cheaper way to move goods comes along.  

Riding on Coattails

Warren Buffett has talked about “riding on coattails”. Well here is a situation where it may be possible to ride on his.  We know what Berkshire has paid for all of its BNI stock.  So we can come up with an idea of what he considers to be a “fair” price. One thing to keep in mind is that in some cases he bought the stock on “puts” which means he collected a premium for taking on the obligation to buy the stock at a certain price.  In these cases he technically paid less than the price reported because that does not reflect the discount for the premium. 

With recent purchases its obvious he thinks its a good deal in the low 60’s and coincidentally it has also recently hit its 52 week low. But am I saying mimic what he does blindly? No.

 The thing I like about this situation is that I can research BNI on my own, come up with my own valuation for the stock, my own opinion and then compare it to someone elses. This someone else just happens to be far more knowledgable then I am. I am not saying buy a stock just because Buffet buys it.

In alot of cases Buffet gets deals that we can’t. With GE and GS he got high interest perferred shares with lots of consequences in his favor. Those are unique and should not be read as “Buffet is buying GE stock!”. While he is technically buying GE stock he is getting alot more reward and protection than anyone buying their common stock. In this case he is buying BNI common stock without any special deals.  

Risks and other thoughts

There are some things to take in consideration when looking at BNI from the perspective of a personal investor:

1. Buffett has to make large investments. There are great companies selling for great prices right now, alot that will probably make you more money than BNI but they are too small for large investors. This is where you have an advantage over Buffet. BNI is a good long term play but for someone who is not managing billions of dollars there are probably better oportunities. 

2. Buyout. It is possible that Buffett is working his way to a complete purchase of BNI for Berkshire Hathaway. If this happens sooner rather than later you will not get the same return and if it were to happen within a year of your purchase date you could pay higher taxes on your gains. Keep in mind there has been no talk of a buyout, but I think its something to consider. 

Personal thoughts

As I mentioned in a previous post, I look at investing as far more than a vehicle for income. I personally like BNI because I live in South Seattle close to alot of rail activity so I constantly get a personal real life view of my holdings and I derive much joy from that.